"My mind rebels at stagnation. Give me problems give me
work, give me the most abstruse cryptogram, or the most
intricate analysis and I am in my own proper atmosphere.
But I abhor the dull routine of existence. I crave for mental exaltation."
Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
"Of all ghosts the ghosts of our old loves are the worst."
Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
26/11/1985: The Black Museum and Its Treasures
Bill Waddell (Curator)
11/3/1986: Fifty Years in Crime the Changing Scheme
Sir Fredrick Lawton
8/11/1986: The Dingo Baby Case (Australia)
Professor J.M. Cameron
3/3/1987: Mrs Livesey: Guilty or Not Guilty? (In 1979, at Preston Crown
Court, Margaret Livesey was found guilty of the murder of her
son. She appealed in 1980, claiming that she had confessed while
confused and that she could not have committed the crime in
the time available to her, but the appeal was dismissed. Following
further campaigning by ‘Justice’, also a TV programme which
questioned the verdict, a second appeal was heard in 1986, but
this too was dismissed.
John Rowe QC (who had represented Mrs Livesey on appeal)
27/9/1987: Murder at the New York Tribune – and Other Instances of
Dementia Americana
Albert Borowitz
22/3/1988: ‘The Babes-in-the-Wood Case’ (The murders of two nine-year old
girls in Brighton in 1986 led to the trial and acquittal of
Russell Bishop who was convicted of attempted murder in an
unrelated case three years later.)
Brian Leary QC
8/11/1988: The A6 Murder, 1961: Trial and Post-Trial Evidence
Jean Justice (who stood in for the intended speaker at very
short notice.
18/4/1989: The Murder of Marilyn Monroe?
Fenton Bresler
5/11/1989: The Paper-Boy Case (Carl Bridgewater)
Jeremy Roberts QC
24/4/1990: Poison by Umbrella (death of Georgi Markov)
Dr. Rufus Crompton
30/10/1990: Ann Chapman: a Greek Tragedy (The murder of a radio reporter
in Athens, 1971.)
Professor David Bowen
9/4/1991: Murder – Man or Animals? (the death of Julie Ward in Kenya)
Professor G. Austin Gresham and John Ward, Julie’s father.
12/11/1991: The Birmingham Six
Graham Boal QC
23/6/1992: The Responsibilities of the Director of Public Prosecutions
Dame Barbara Mills QC
22/11/1992: The Craig and Bentley Case
Robin Odell
30/11/1993: Writing About Crime
(The first Dinner following the death of Henry Elam.)
Jonathan Goodman
22/3/1994: The Great Train Robbery: Thirty Years On
Keith Milner QPM
25/5/1994: Jeremy Bamber and the White House Farm Murders
Roger Wilkes
8/11/1994: Myra Hindley: a Different Case? (The next morning, the Daily Star (then subtitled ‘The No. 1 Paper for NEWS’) carried a front-page story which read, in small part: ‘A secret meeting – a Dogooders’ Summit – was held last night to plot the next move in the campaign to free child-killer Myra Hindley. News of the discussion over a four-course meal at the Imperial Hotel is bound to spark outrage … ‘Ann West, mother of Lesley Ann Downey, was quoted as saying that we were ‘a bunch of twisted weirdos’ – and, compounding the libel, the paper commented on the untrue story in its first leading article.
The Rev. Peter Timms (special guests: the Hon. David Astor,
CH, and his wife Bridget; Benedict Birnberg, Ian Brady’s
solicitor; Lord and Lady Longford; Andrew McCooey, Myra
Hindley’s solicitor)
14/2/1995: The Leaders of London’s Gangland
James Morton and Leonard ‘Nipper’ Read
23/5/1995: O.J. Simpson: America’s Latest Crime of the Century
Albert Borowitz
31/10/1995: Further Developments in the Julie Ward Case
John Ward (who stood in for the intended speaker at very
short notice)
26/3/1996: The Armstrong Poisoning Case (Hay-on-Wye, 1921)
Robin Odell (‘for the prosecution’) and Martin Beales (‘for the
defence’)
26/3/1996: A Most Unusual Inquest – which the speaker had conducted on
Ascension Island (The first Members-only Dinner for 89 years)
Sir Montague B. Levine
16/5/1996: Aspects of Forensic Pathology (including a discussion of the West
mass-murder case, Gloucester)
Professor Bernard Knight, CBE (followed by comments from
Brian Leveson, QC, who had led for the Crown at the trial of
Mrs Rosemary West, Winchester, 1995)
12/11/1996: Operation Orchid: the inquiry into crimes by paedophiles in
East London, 1989-92
Ex-Detective Chief Inspector David Easy
4/2/1997: Scandal at the Savoy (the killing of Ali Kamel Fahmy Bey by his
wife Marguerite, 1923)
Andrew Rose
25/3/1997: The Disappearance of Lord Lucan
H H Judge Brian Watling QC (who had represented the
Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police at the inquest)
13/5/1997: Experts and the Law – with reference to some recent criminal
trials in which the speaker had appeared as counsel
Anthony Scrivener QC
4/2/1998: Matricide at the Metropole: the Sidney Fox case, Margate 1929
Andrew Rose; H H Allan King-Hamilton QC, recalled the
trial of Fox (Lewes Assizes, 1929, at which he was the Judge’s
Marshal
24/3/1998: A British War Criminal?
Sir Peter Badge (who, as Chief Metropolitan Stipendiary
Magistrate, had committed Szymon Serafinowicz for trial)
followed by comments from John Nutting, QC and William
Clegg, QC respectively Crown Counsel and Defence Counsel at
both the committal proceedings and the truncated trial.
12/5/1998: A Whiff of Homicide (The speaker, Emeritus Professor of
Anaesthesia at the University of London, discussed illegal uses of
anaesthetics, dealing in particular with a trial at Chelmsford
Crown Court in 1984 in which he was an expert witness for the
defence: following the death of Betty Amor from inhalation of
chloroform, apparently used as an aphrodisiac by herself and her
lover, a research chemist, named David Harvey, the latter charged
with murder, was convicted of manslaughter, for which he
received a suspended sentence.)
Professor James Payne
27/10/1998: The Murder of Rachel Nickell on Wimbledon Common
William Clegg QC (who had successfuly defended Colin Stagg)
26/1/1999: The Case of the Green-Tailed Mare:
the trial of Aleck Bourne, FRCS
H H Judge Brian Watling QC
16/3/1999: The Rajneesh Murder Conspiracy (against the US Attorney for
Oregon) Andrew McCooey (one of the defendants, Sally-Anne
Croft, was present and answered questions)
11/5/1999: Ripper Diaries: Fact or Fiction?
Shirley Harrison and Keith Skinner
23/11/1999: Professor Higgins and the Courtroom
Dr Peter French, Forensic Speech Scientist
24/1/2000: The Case of Private Lee Clegg
William Clegg QC
28/3/2000: Zeebrugge to Ladbroke Grove:
Disasters of All Kinds and How to Deal with Them
David Calvert-Smith QC
9/5/2000: The Hungerford Shootings
Dr Richard Shepherd
16/1/2001: The Babes in the Wood Case
Iain Sproat and Leonard “Nipper” Read
6/3/2001: The Shooting of Steven Waldorf
Michael Bradley Taylor
16/4/2001: The Confessions of John Duffy – The So-called Railway
Murderer Det.Supt. Leslie Bolland
13/11/2001: The Morgan Axe Murder
Sir Montague B. Levine
5/3/2002: Conan Doyle as Sherlock Homes
Richard Lancelyn Green
14/5/2002: The Charles Angus Murder Case
Glenn Chandler
19/11/2002: The Murder of Jill Dando
Orlando Pownall QC
18/2/2003: Tara Perry – Facing the Electric Chair
Andrew McCooey
6/5/2003: UK Response to 9/11
Dr Richard Shepherd
2/12/2003: What Makes a Classic Murder Case?
(Club Centenary Dinner)
Jonathan Goodman, James Morton, Andrew Rose and
Robin Odell
16/3/2004: The Attempted Theft of a Fortune in Diamonds from the
Millennium Dome
Martin Heslop QC
20/4/2004: Deedes on Murder
Lord “Bill” Deedes
28/9/2004: A Queer Affair: The Mysterious Life and Death of Leslie Holt
Professor James Payne
30/11/2004: The Soham Murders
Dr Nathaniel Cary
18/1/2005: The Sheffield Gang Wars
Julian Broadhurst
4/10/2005: Mr. Kipper and Suzy Lamplugh
Robin Odell
7/2/2006: The Denver Society Murder
Jonathan Goodman
9/5/2006: Getting Away with Murder
HM Coroner Dr Paul Knapman
7/11/2006: The Death of David Kelly and How the West was Spun
Tom Mangold
13/2/2007: Conscientious Objection and the Gulf War;
The Case of Gunner Williams
HHJ Gordon Risius CB
16/4/2007: From Hero to Zero: The Rise and Fall of the Medical Witness
Professor Michael Green
15/5/2007: The Murder of Frank Mitchell: The Mad Axeman
Leonard “Nipper” Read
4/12/2007: Sex Crimes and Misdemeanours: A Christmas Entertainment
James Morton
26/2/2008: Sir Bernard Spilsbury: Hero or Villain?
Andrew Rose
15/4/2008: The Siege of Sidney Street
Donald Rumbelow
17/2/2009: The Murder of PC Gutteridge
Robin Odell
12/5/2009: Defending Barry George: The murderer of Jill Dando
William Clegg QC
10/11/2009: The Golden Age? Murder between the Wars
P.D.James
9/2/2010: Operation Mincemeat – New Light on The Man Who Never
Was
Ben Macintyre
11/5/2010: Salieri and The Murder of Mozart
Albert Borowitz
23/11/2010: The Centenary of Dr Crippen (Executed 23rd November 1910):
A Miscarriage of Justice?
John Cooper QC
19/4/2011: Provocation as a Defence to Murder: The Rene Duffy Case
Professor Susan Edwards
31/5/2011: The Bermuda Triangle
Tom Mangold
4/10/2011: 1888 And All That: A Year of Invention and Creativity with
Criminal Undertones
Robin Odell
13/12/2011: Was George Davis Innocent?
David Whitehouse QC
7/2/2012: R v Barker: Baby P and Child Witnesses – Lessons learnt by one
Shell-shocked QC
Bernard Richmond QC
16/10/2012: On Getting Into Killers’ Shoes
Professor David Canter
4/12/2012: The Trial of Jeremy Bamber and After
Anthony Arlidge QC
12/3/2013: Aftermath: The Omagh Bombing and the Families pursuit of
Justice’
Ruth Dudley Edwards
15/5/2013: The True Story of Burke and Hare
HM Coroner Christopher Dorries
15/10/2013: Neville Heath. War Hero, Conman, Killer
Sean O’Connor
3/12/2013: Looking Back and Dropping Names
Moray Watson
11/3/2014: John Christie: The Mind of a Murderer
Dr Jonathan Oates
6/5/2014: Ian Brady: Prison or Hospital
HH Judge Robert Atherton on his ruling that the Moors murderer should remain in a maximum-security hospital due to insanity
14/10/2014: Female Murderers I Have Known
Dr Ann Coxon
2/12/2014: A Christmas Causerie
Robin Odell
10/3/2015: Poison is a Woman's Weapon
Angela Brabin
12/5/2015: Escape from Broadmoor: The Trials and Strangulations of John Thomas Straffen
Gordon Lowe
13/10/2015: Cricket's Dark Side
David Frith
8/12/2015: The Work of the Forensic Toxicologist in Three Cases
Dr Simon Elliott. Included cause of death by alcohol intoxication of singer Amy Winehouse
8/3/2016: Prisoner 4374: Poisoner Neill Cream
A.J. Griffiths-Jones
10/5/2016: The Acid Bath Murders. The Trials and Liquidations of John George Haigh
Gordon Lowe
18/10/2016: The Name is Kray A film on the Kray twins with footage and interviews not seen since their conviction in 1969
Tom Mangold
13/12/2016: Dickens, Pickwick & Christmas
Professor Tony Pointon
14/3/2017: Suffollk Strangler Steven Wright, 2006 serial killer of five sex workers.
Solicitor Mark Haslam
9/5/2017: Triple murderer John Merret AKA "The Amazing Mr Chesney".Author Jonathan Oates
10/10/2017: Daisy Wallace's brutal stabbing in 1949 remains unsolved despite here explicit diary entries.
Solicitor & author James Morton
13/3/2018: Marshall Hall 'A law unto himself'. Career of the Edwardian celebrity barrister.
Author & QC Sally Smith
8/5/2018: The A6 murderer, James Hanratty. One of the final executions in the UK found not be a miscarriage of justice following new DNA evidence. Retired Detective Paul Stickler.
9/10/2018: Murder in Mile End, a case Conan Doyle couldn't solve but our speaker claims he has. 1860 murder of Mary Emsley.
Author Sinclair McKay
21/11/2018: Jeremy Thorpe's 1975 attempted murder of Norman Scott, film with new evidence on those involved.
Reporter Tom Mangold
12/3/2019: Sir Harry Oakes (gold miner and philanthropist) 1943 murder, still unsolved.
Retired Detective Paul Stickler.
14/5/2019: Forensic science and the misinterpretation of evidenceProfessor Ruth Morgan
10/9/2019: Muriel McKay kidnap and murder. Film presentation with unheard audio from the 1969 ransom tapes.
Reporter Tom Mangold
26/12/2019: 'The Body in the Bag'. GCHQ worker Gareth Williams likely died accidentally in 2010 while enacting a sexual fetish.
Pathologist Richard Shepherd.
10/3/2020: The Porthole murder. James Camb convicted of murdering Actress Gay Gibson who went missing aboard a ship in 1947.
Retired Detective Paul Stickler standing in for a cancellation.
N.B. this was our last meeting at the outbreak of the Covid-19 pandemic. September and December's meetings were cancelled.
Though quite considerable research has gone into the compilation of this list, a few titles or papers remain opaque, and in some instances it has not been possible to ascertain the title of the paper and/or the name of the speaker. If any member can solve any of the mysteries, he or she is requested to tell the Honorary Secretary.